Search

Controversial plans to build 78 new homes refused

PUBLISHED: 06:30 16 March 2018 | UPDATED: 13:13 16 March 2018

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

Archant © 2018

A controversial outline planning proposal to build 78 new homes in Carlton Colville has been unanimously refused – much to the delight of concerned residents.

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused.
Picture: Nick ButcherPlanning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

The bid would have seen a new housing estate built within the setting of St Peter’s Church, a Grade II* listed building, on the land at Church Lane and Chapel Road.

It originally came before Waveney District Council’s (WDC) planning committee last month; however councillors voted to visit the greenfield site to more accurately assess the community impact before reaching a final decision.

As the application was brought back to the committee on Tuesday evening some residents were forced to watch proceedings via a link in the canteen as available seating overflowed.

Residents, councillors and Historic England have continually voiced concerns the proposal will negatively impact the setting of the church and nearby residents.

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused.
Picture: Nick ButcherPlanning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

St Peter’s Church is the oldest recorded building in the town. It was originally built in 1326, then rebuilt in 1884, and is Grade II* listed – meaning it is a particularly important building of more than special interest.

Historic England objected to the application and said developing the last open area of land in the setting of the church would result in harm to the significance of the building.

During the meeting representatives from Badger Building, who submitted the bid, attacked the “narrow-minded” views of Historic England.

They said: “The church’s purpose is unaffected by setting. Churches serve people not fields.

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused.
Picture: Nick ButcherPlanning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

“Our plan adds housing to a faltering housing supply.”

The proposed scheme also outlined plans to provide extra parking for the church to meet modern needs.

During the debate committee members agreed the site’s proximity to the listed church was grounds enough to refuse the plan.

However questions were also raised about whether the area’s existing infrastructure could cope with an influx of residents.

Planning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick ButcherPlanning permission to build 78 homes opposite St Peter's Church, Carlton Colville has been refused. Picture: Nick Butcher

Councillor Graham Elliott noted the current draft of WDC’s Local Plan, which is formally released next week, rejected the site.

He said: “We have to allocate sites – if we don’t we lose all control of our planning system.

“This site was assessed and ruled out.

“We owe it to our local residents to deliver our local plan and not sites on top of that.”

The councillors’ decision was greeted with a wave of cheering and applause by relieved residents.

Other news

The tragic death of a woman in a crash on the A12 has sparked further calls for the road’s safety issues to be tackled.

16:24

A woman has died in a serious crash in north Suffolk – the second road fatality in the county during the past week.

18:00

It is the culmination of almost five years of hard work.

17:12

An army veteran who smothered his girlfriend with a duvet after an argument claimed he was ‘wiping away her tears’.

Most Read

16:24

A woman has died in a serious crash in north Suffolk – the second road fatality in the county during the past week.

Read more
Suffolk police
16:22

The 90-year-old man who was found with serious injuries at the Suffolk home where his wife’s lifeless body was discovered, has also died.

Read more
Suffolk police

The owner of the building whose alarm rang for five days in Lowestoft has apologised for the irritation - but blamed his former tenants for the disruption.

Read more
Lowestoft
07:47

A drink driver suffering short-term memory loss drove his Jaguar the wrong way down the A47 after following a satnav, a court has heard.

Read more
Great Yarmouth Magistrates' Court
Yesterday, 19:03

A serious crash closed the A12 in both directions between Wangford and Wrentham last night.

Read more
Suffolk Police

Autumn Supplement

cover

Click here to view
the Autumn
Supplement

View

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 15°C

min temp: 9°C

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Lowestoft Journal
e-edition today

Subscribe

Newsletter Sign Up

Lowestoft Journal weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy