Search

Commissioners recommend closing Southwold and Patrick Stead hospitals permanently as part of system shake-up

07:00 03 November 2015

Patrick Stead Hospital is one of two hospitals recommended for closure.  Picture: James Bass

Patrick Stead Hospital is one of two hospitals recommended for closure. Picture: James Bass

Archant Norfolk © 2015

The fates of two much-loved hospitals have been all but sealed after health bosses announced their recommendation to axe both services permanently.

Great Yarmouth and Waveney Clinical Commissioning Group (HealthEast) wants to close Southwold and Halesworth’s Patrick Stead hospitals and replace them with out-of-hospital services and beds in care homes.

The recommendation was met with disappointment by campaigners, who fear for the impact on patients.

HealthEast’s governing body will make the final decision on Thursday.

It comes after a public consultation in which around 56pc of the 1,181 who responded were against the closures.

In a separate question 53pc said they were in favour of introducing out-of-hospital teams in the community.

Closing 15 beds at Northgate Hospital, Great Yarmouth, and five beds at All Hallows Hospital, Ditchingham are also included in the recommendation.

The 21 beds at Beccles Hospital will also cater for longer-term patients with more complex needs than previously.

It is hoped the closures will save HealthEast £4.3m per year and take pressure off James Paget University Hospital (JPH) at Gorleston.

But chief executive Andy Evans insisted the move was “not about cuts” and added it formed part of HealthEast’s strategy for the next 10 to 15 years.

“This is about changing the way we provide care for our people,” he said.

“Patients will get better care provided by out-of-hospital teams in their own homes.”

He stressed that none of the closures will be implemented until HealthEast has developed the new services.

But Southwold Hospital has been effectively closed since August after its operator, East Coast Community Healthcare, was unable to provide safe staffing levels.

Brian Jolly, chairman of the League of Friends of Southwold and District Hospital, said the process had left “a bitter taste”.

“What we’re a bit disappointed about is the fact that there’s been no interim measures put into place after the hospital closed,” he said.

“We always knew they would go ahead with the proposals.

“We would like to work with HealthEast to find a solution to the situation.”

He said the group would have been supportive of the plan had the new planned care home at Sole Bay Health Centre, Reydon, already been in place.

Patrick Stead Hospital could close by 2018, according to Mr Evans.

He said he “hoped” there would be no staffing issues to threaten an early closure of the hospital before the new services are in place.

He said HealthEast would work intensively over the next three to six months to develop the new services across its whole area.

Anne Fleming, chairman of Halesworth Town Council, said: “The uncertainty of the future of the hospitals means that staff are looking for jobs elsewhere.

“I think it will close down before 2018 because they will say they can’t staff it.”

David Thomas, a town councillor, said he welcomed Mr Evans’ statement about new services being in place before closing beds.

He said: “It reassures the town council that Andy Evans is sticking to his word that he gave at the public meeting.”

Asked how much of a difference to the outcome the consultation had made, Mr Evans said HealthEast had taken the views of the public into consideration by recognising the need to develop different models of care for each individual area.

HealthEast had previously planned to roll out a model across the 
whole area based on its pilot programme in Lowestoft, where emergency admissions to the JPH have decreased in the last 18 months.

It is by preventing expensive hospital admissions and instead paying for patients’ care in their own homes or communities that HealthEast hopes to save money.

At Thursday’s meeting the governing body will also discuss HealthEast’s recommendation to build a new site at Shrublands, Gorleston, from which to deliver GP services to residents of the Gorleston and Bradwell areas.

See today’s paper edition of the EDP for more reaction and analysis.

What do you think? Write, giving full contact details, to the Letters Editor, Prospect House, Rouen Road, Norwich, NR1 1RE.

4 comments

  • It is surprising to read that emergency admissions have been reduced by the pilot scheme, when last week it was reported that emergency admissions to JPH were up 6.4% in October compared to last year and that the hospital is on 'Black Alert'. Also, data released in the hospital's annual report shows an increase in clinical activity in all areas, including in A+E, from 201314 to 201415.

    Report this comment

    Bungay123

    Thursday, November 5, 2015

  • I am surprised, after the lies told about the these cuts and Mental Health Services cuts not being about saving money, that Andy Evans's nose doesn't reach from Lowestoft to Yarmouth!

    Report this comment

    Dogberry

    Thursday, November 5, 2015

  • This is about saving money. Nothing else. The JPH and N &N will be bed-blocked by patients who would otherwise have been transferred to these hospitals. A false economy, a crass decision and a terrible news for those patients whose social circumstances preclude them from being cared for at home, or, being blunt, would prefer that their lives end in hospital, not at home. The views of the local population ignored. The silence of the Gt Yarmouth, Waveney and Suffolk Coastal MP's is, not surprisingly, deafening.

    Report this comment

    Fat Controller

    Tuesday, November 3, 2015

  • It`s all about saving money . The out-of-hospital teams will be people who are rushed off their feet because they have too many visits to make in a day . Old people living on their own will suffer the most .

    Report this comment

    dragonfly

    Tuesday, November 3, 2015

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Other news

Launch of the Eastern Daily Press 2016 Stars of Lowestoft and Waveney awards.
Mick Parker and mayor, Stephen Ardley with Woody Bear.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

Dozens of hard-working and deserving people have been nominated for this year’s Stars of Lowestoft and Waveney Awards - but there is still time to get your entries in.

15:05
New Anglia Local Enterprise Partnership, together with Norfolk and Suffolk Chambers of Commerce, host a business engagement events at UCS, to give businesses in the East the opportunity to learn more about the benefits of devolution. 
Panel of speakers Chris Starkie Chris Bally Dr Peter Funnell Andy Wood OBE Mark Pendlington answer relevant questions

Business leaders from across east Suffolk have come together to back proposals for the region to get more devolved powers from the government.

13:04
An East of England Ambulance Service Trust ambulance on the way to an emergency. Photograph Simon Parker

A man had to be cut free from his vehicle after it careered off the road and into a ditch.

Ivan Humble  is urging people to report intolerance in the wake of the Brexit vote.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

“We need to make sure intolerance isn’t brought into our community” – that is the message from community leaders across Waveney today after fears a rise in hate crime is taking place under the radar.

Most Read

Yesterday, 17:00
Pet chickens Edna, Gertrude and Betty were stolen from a home in Carlton Colville.

A family has spoken of its heartbreak as three beloved pet chickens were stolen from their home.

Read more
Carlton Colville
13:04
An East of England Ambulance Service Trust ambulance on the way to an emergency. Photograph Simon Parker

A man had to be cut free from his vehicle after it careered off the road and into a ditch.

Read more
James Paget University Hospital
Yesterday, 08:15
Enjoying the bid to become sandcastle building record breakers at Lowestoft. Picture: Mick Howes

They fought with determination, doing the spadework to turn the tide of history.

Read more
Friday, July 22, 2016
Travellers on Normanston Park, Lowestoft.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

A meeting is to be held by Waveney District Council on Monday after Travellers moved on to a Lowestoft park.

Read more
Suffolk police
Yesterday, 09:46
A commemorative Victoria Cross stone being unveiled in Lowestoft in memory of Claude Castleton who fought in the First World War.
During the service.

Picture: James Bass

He was an ordinary man who made the most extraordinary of sacrifices on a First World War battlefield.

Read more
Sonia Barker

Most Commented

Ivan Humble  is urging people to report intolerance in the wake of the Brexit vote.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

“We need to make sure intolerance isn’t brought into our community” – that is the message from community leaders across Waveney today after fears a rise in hate crime is taking place under the radar.

Read more
Colin Law
Yesterday, 12:00
Claud Castleton, from Lowestoft, who was awarded the Victoria Cross in the first world war

The Lowestoft builder’s son with a thirst for adventure had been seeking his fortune in one of the remotest corners of the British empire when war broke out.

Read more
Ormiston Denes Academy

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 22°C

min temp: 17°C

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Lowestoft Journal
e-edition today

Subscribe

Newsletter Sign Up